Civic Design at Scale: Introducing the Public Policy Layer Cake
Summary
When designing into inherently complex government services, civic designers must take a systemic approach. Too often service design focuses on public-facing and sometimes frontline staff-facing interventions, thereby placing the burden of successful service delivery on unempowered shoulders. As service delivery is the byproduct of many entities, interventions must systemically target all policy "layers", such as operations and policy, to be successful. In this presentation, the Public Policy Lab team will share their public policy 'layer cake'. Besides reflecting their affinity for baked goods, it’s a systems design framework for creating interventions at all levels of a public service, while also creating opportunities for equity.
Key Insights
-
•
Public services involve multiple layers of human roles with varying power, not just frontline staff.
-
•
Service design must address policies, protocols, and operational structures, not only public-facing tools.
-
•
The 'layer cake' framework maps where and what kind of power exists in government service delivery systems.
-
•
In the Family Pathways to Care project, co-design with caregivers and staff improved intake and referral processes.
-
•
Operational and policy level tools like standardized protocols and data dashboards support frontline service improvements.
-
•
Public feedback channels operating at the organizational level amplify family voices beyond individual service encounters.
-
•
Shared mental models and program typologies help actors at all levels align and make systemic decisions.
-
•
Civic participation tools (e.g., crowdsourcing or participatory budgeting) represent important 'consensus products' in public service ecosystems.
-
•
Designing for systemic change requires understanding and intervening in the interactions between people, tools, rules, and resources.
-
•
Systems change ultimately happens at the human scale by making invisible structures visible and open to redesign.
Notable Quotes
"Service delivery is led by frontline staff who tend to have the least amount of power in the system."
"Public services are a multi-layered culmination of people and products, not just a single entity."
"The layer cake framework helps notice where and what kind of power actually resides in systems."
"Even the best-designed public-facing tools need operational and policy support to succeed."
"We developed family-facing intake tools to make the service experience more transparent and equitable."
"A standard framework for collecting and responding to family feedback at the organizational level can increase their voice’s impact."
"Shared mental models serve as organizing frameworks that all players in the system can understand and make decisions within."
"Putting all programs together on easily comparable terms makes the system material and conceivable."
"Systems change happens at the human scale by making structures and humans visible so we can investigate and change them together."
"Designers hope to support the public in exercising agency and redistribute hegemonic power in public services."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"Embracing uncertainty means diving in without knowing the outcome and creating something new every time."
Jim KalbachJazz Improvisation as a Model for Team Collaboration
November 6, 2017
"A really strong book has to be designed as a journey with a consistent voice guiding the reader."
Louis RosenfeldCoffee with Lou: Should You Write a (UX) Book?
March 7, 2024
"The difference between director and principal often lies in whether you’re inspired more by leading people or focused on outputs and craft."
Catt Small Micah Bennett Brian Carr Jessica HarlleeWhat's Next for ICs: Exploring Staff and Principal Designer Roles
February 22, 2024
"We can’t be there for every behavior after the nudge, nor do we necessarily want to be."
Marieke McCloskeyUser Science: Product Analytics & User Research
March 11, 2021
"Blurring user faces loses context and doesn’t address voice privacy, making it an inadequate solution."
Llewyn Paine[Demo] Deploying AI doppelgangers to de-identify user research recordings
June 5, 2024
"Random assignment to treatment or control is essential—if it’s not random, it’s not a true experiment."
Joshua NobleCasual Inference
October 6, 2023
"Empathy doesn’t come from reading a report—you don’t get close to users by just reading data."
Sara LogelYour Colleagues are Your Users Too
March 29, 2023
"Learning is a marathon, not a sprint, especially in the context of online conferences."
Bria Alexander Louis RosenfeldWelcome
January 8, 2024
"More ways to contact support—chat, email, phone—are essential because different disabilities require different options."
Sam ProulxOnline Shopping: Designing an Accessible Experience
June 7, 2023