Fair and Effective Designer Evaluation
Summary
How do you evaluate designers fairly and effectively while providing a clear path toward career advancement? This is a question our organization has grappled with throughout our eight years as a company. Design can often be left up to gut reasoning by leadership and designers may not have a clear understanding of what their role means and how they may grow as designers. We’ve developed iterations of different tools and processes over the years to address these concerns and to evolve with our shifting needs as a growing company. All of which has led us to a robust tool that we’ve been using over the past two years which can serve as a model for how organizations can deploy qualitative career advancement. The session will cover our journey to this point and showcase the tools and processes we’ve deployed to make evaluation and career advancement systematic within a design organization along with surprising benefits and lessons we’ve learned along the way.
Key Insights
-
•
Grant Studio’s career path system evaluates designers in craft, quality, client, and team categories to drive well-rounded growth.
-
•
Continuous anonymous feedback after projects keeps evaluation timely and focused on individual goals.
-
•
Performance evaluations happen twice yearly and aggregate feedback from multiple project leads.
-
•
A Google Sheets tool was chosen over commercial software for flexibility and control over the evaluation structure.
-
•
Weighting of evaluation categories varies by role level; craft and quality dominate for designers, client and team for leads.
-
•
Career managers mentor designers and advocate for them in staffing and promotions.
-
•
The system promotes generalists who can work holistically across projects rather than specialists.
-
•
Grant Studio removed the 'studio development' category after realizing designers deprioritized extracurricular activities due to workload.
-
•
There is a recognized challenge in evaluating non-linear career moves and leadership roles within the current linear career path.
-
•
Transparency and collective involvement in the evaluation system foster buy-in and make difficult career conversations fairer.
Notable Quotes
"Evaluations and promotions can be nebulous and awkward, especially in collaborative design work."
"We built a career path to make evaluations as fair and consistent as possible across roles."
"Continuous feedback is anonymous and focused on teammates’ goals to help keep focus on what matters most."
"Our evaluation tool is a Google Sheet so we can quickly make adjustments without being bogged down by unnecessary features."
"The system encourages growth not just in craft but also in client engagement and team collaboration."
"We want to build consultants who can solve problems across a variety of projects and clients."
"Career managers develop close relationships with designers and advocate for staffing and promotions on their behalf."
"We’ve had to retire the studio development category because it wasn’t prioritized due to project work demands."
"The career path shows when someone is ready for promotion, but additional training may be needed to support leadership transitions."
"Transparency is one of our key values, so everyone in the studio was involved in building and maintaining the evaluation system."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"Kids love to play. They challenge the world through games and simulation, so the things we create need to support play and experimentation."
Nathan Shedroff Hugh Dubberly Thomas J. McLeishHow Will Design be Taught When the Schools Shut Down?
May 8, 2026
"We use this data not to dehumanize, but to elevate each person’s uniqueness and fairly incentivize performance."
John Paul de Guzman10k Screens Later: How We Became a Data-Driven Design Organization
September 24, 2024
"There are over five hundred tools that call themselves survey software on G2, making it one of the largest software categories."
Aleksandra Korczynska Caroline Jarrett Justyna ParmeeSurvey Tools
March 12, 2026
"Teamwork makes the dream work – something we all learned in primary school and still holds true."
Kristin SkinnerTheme 2: Introduction and Provocation
January 8, 2024
"The community is a big tent - welcoming diverse perspectives and geographies to define and shape civic design."
Rachael Dietkus, LCSW Victor Udoewa Jennifer StricklandEverything You Need to Know about the Civic Design 2022 Call for Presentations
May 17, 2022
"Are we feeling trapped in this thing called UX design, limited by mechanized processes like agile?"
Uday GajendarThe Rise of Meta-Design: A Starter Playbook
May 19, 2022
"The hidden hero or villain of craft is really feedback, the quality of feedback that we give."
Vanessa VarinFeedback: The Other F-Word
September 10, 2025
"Digital twins are replicas of dynamic systems that help both individuals and populations manage and improve operations."
Hugh DubberlyProblems with Problems: Reconsidering the Frame of Designing as Problem-Solving
June 19, 2019
"Engineers started questioning old assumptions and product wasn’t just adjusting roadmaps, they were reframing decisions around user needs."
Sean McKayCoexisting with non-researchers: Practical strategies for a democratized research future
March 11, 2025
