That Quiet Little Voice: When Design and Ethics Collide
Summary
The design industry’s relationship to the field of business has long been established and continues to become further entangled each year. But designers aren’t just satisfied with only disrupting the business sector—they’re keen to disrupt the social sector too. Unfortunately, the weaknesses baked into the discipline of design (that have been present from the start) are readily exposed when designers enter complex social issues and treat them like any other human-centered innovation challenge. The lack of a moral framework, let alone a set of ethical guidelines, put designers at great risk of doing more harm than good.
Key Insights
-
•
Human-centered design can be weaponized to exploit users, as seen in the founding of Jewel Labs.
-
•
The design industry largely relies on individual designers’ personal ethics (BYOE), lacking a shared ethical framework.
-
•
Dieter Rams’ principles of good design focus on function and honesty but do not prevent ethically harmful products.
-
•
Power asymmetry is embedded in most design projects, with designers often lacking influence compared to powerful clients.
-
•
Greater Good Studio practices 'breaking up' with projects to avoid causing harm, a rare and vital practice in the industry.
-
•
Saying no to projects requires cultivation and support, as designers are typically trained to always say yes.
-
•
Design primarily serves to build capital and provide comfort, which attracts powerful stakeholders and can accelerate harm.
-
•
There is widespread unacknowledged workplace trauma and ethical conflict within design teams.
-
•
An ethical design framework could include codes of ethics, accreditation, licensing, and community feedback mechanisms.
-
•
The design industry risks bifurcation into accountable designers serving demanding clients and an unaccountable majority.
Notable Quotes
"Good design is honest and yes, the Jewel e-cigarette will honestly kill you."
"What is design’s relationship to power and privilege? Which humans do we center when we say human-centered design?"
"Power is the ability to change another person’s reality."
"The most common way people give up their power is by thinking they don’t have any."
"We mostly have something called a BYOE scenario or bring your own ethics."
"Not every project needs to be responded to; not every RFP needs a proposal."
"Every major brand has a dark side brought to you by design on purpose, 40 hours a week."
"Design helps build capital and seek comfort, which draws in the most powerful."
"Why do designers decide how to design this? How do we wean design's addiction from whiteness?"
"Saying no shouldn’t be about being difficult but about accountability beyond any one person."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"If you’re rewarding designers for delivering on time, great, but if you reward them for delivering accessible products on time, you’ll get better results."
Sheri Byrne-HaberAccessibility at Scale
June 9, 2021
"Most users don't know what they want until you show it to them."
Prayag Narula Hannah HudsonEmpowering Designers to do Good Research
March 11, 2022
"When I first started, I felt like I had this little superpower that nobody else really knew about."
Janelle EstesUX Research Trends
January 28, 2021
"We often get designed into a corner by trying to fix words at the end instead of involving content designers earlier."
Craig Brookes Andreas Huebner Morgan Quinn"Just Make it Look Good" and Other Ways We're Misunderstood
June 11, 2021
"The community is an ongoing prototype; members have a strong, frequent voice in shaping what good looks like."
Marc Fonteijn Ru ButlerIncrease your confidence, influence, and impact (through a Professional Community)
December 3, 2024
"Research ops is heavily reliant on clear and consistent research leadership to define strategy and priorities."
Kate TowseyThe State of ResearchOps: More Than Just Theory
June 20, 2019
"Our nervous system is ancient; it can’t tell the difference between an angry email and a tiger lurking."
Alla WeinbergDesign Teams Need Psychological Safety: Here’s How to Create It
September 9, 2022
"We have over 30 contracting teams spread across roughly 10 vendors all working on parts of the veteran experience landscape."
Shawna Hein Kevin HoffmanCreate a Cohesive Civic Design Practice Across Agency, Vendors, and Contracts
November 17, 2022
"I've thrived on being wrong and making mistakes, even when I wasn't actually wrong."
Tricia WangSCALE: Discussion
June 15, 2018
